Reviews

Sam's has been a familiar lunch and dinner spot on Gedney for many years. I had kind of stopped dining... read moreSam's has been a familiar lunch and dinner spot on Gedney for many years. I had kind of stopped dining out much during the worst of the pandemic, and upon returning to Sam's, was very pleasantly surprised by all the changes and renovations that had occurred. They managed to preserve what was great about the old Sam's, but provide meaningful upgrades in every respect. The interior and outdoor patio area have been beautifully renovated. The menu retains many traditional favorites, but also offers an abundance of new and inspired dishes. The atmosphere is comfortable enough to just pop in for a bite, yet elegant enough to also serve as destination for a special occasion or family gathering. In fact, Sam's has become a go to destination when friends and family visit; the service is great, and the way they effortlessly accommodate vegan or gluten free requests is especially appreciated. We've enjoyed several wonderful lunches and dinners there in recent months, and eagerly look forward to our next visit! read less

Brody Anniversary Party We just had our 50th anniversary party on the patio at Sam's of Gedney Way. We were so pleased... read moreWe just had our 50th anniversary party on the patio at Sam's of Gedney Way. We were so pleased with the entire event from start to finish and making the arrangements was easy. The venue was lovely. The staff was friendly, responsive to our requests, and efficient. All the food was delicious--appetizers (mushroom straws, cauliflower pizza, and Korean spiced cauliflower), salad, entrees (salmon and chicken especially), and desserts. The meal was paced well and all our guests commented on what a lovely event it was. Thank Sam's! read less

Just had our 50th anniversary party on the patio and could not be happier with the food and the service.... read moreJust had our 50th anniversary party on the patio and could not be happier with the food and the service. Every dish from appetizer to dessert was presented well and delicious. The staff was friendly and attentive. All our guests said how much they enjoyed the venue. Planning was easy and they accommodated several dietary needs such as vegan. read less

New look- Same location, totally renovated, new menu, still great staff & great owners. Great quality food! It... read moreNew look- Same location, totally renovated, new menu, still great staff & great owners. Great quality food! It is my go to restaurant any night I'm too tired to cook! read less

Oh my best lobster roll; magic and the fries crispy and wonderfully seasoned with a spice that included paprika? Whatever... read moreOh my best lobster roll; magic and the fries crispy and wonderfully seasoned with a spice that included paprika? Whatever both were, cooking secrets. Ate by myself because I just wanted something to eat and realized Sam' was the one choice I could make to get a clean well lit table, smooth service, a warm welcome (they make you feel happy you came). I suggest you ask, 'where would you like me to sit' when they ask you where you would like to sit, and see if you are good; I was. Thank you 'Sam's' read less

Had brunch - very good but a small selection - wish there was more to choose from. They did a... read moreHad brunch - very good but a small selection - wish there was more to choose from. They did a renovation & the place looks beautiful! read less

Delicious food! My fiancé and I went for our food tasting for our wedding and were blown away. Every appetizer,... read moreDelicious food! My fiancé and I went for our food tasting for our wedding and were blown away. Every appetizer, entree, dessert was crafted to perfection and the service was top notch. Also, the space itself is clean and looks brand new. 10/10 recommend. read less

Try the brussel sprouts!!! Everything else is also awesome!!!

After reading about Sam's of Gedney Way repeatedly on the Westchester Foodies group we had to check it out for... read moreAfter reading about Sam's of Gedney Way repeatedly on the Westchester Foodies group we had to check it out for date night. Exceptional from start to finish. Beautiful and spacious, apps (burrata and heirlooms and French onion soup), mains (lobster roll and crab cakes) and dessert (strawberry mousse) were all superb. Oh! And the cocktails....I mean...

Everyone there was also as friendly as could be.
Walk over to Emma's Ale House after for a drink - the adorable bartender there infuses his own pineapple vodka. Yummy! read less